This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy via our links, at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure →
The Coselena sandwich platter trays sit alongside the Zumart and ebake trays in the reusable lidded catering tray segment, but they bring one physical feature neither rival offers: a textured base. Where the Zumart and ebake bases are smooth PET plastic, the Coselena tray has a textured underside designed to resist sliding when carried, stacked, or placed on smooth surfaces. Whether that differentiator justifies the premium over Zumart’s 10-pack pricing depends on how you plan to use the trays. At £9.42 for five (£1.88 per tray), the 5-pack entry price is higher than both the Zumart 6-pack (£1.33 per tray) and the ebake 6-pack (£1.50 per tray). The 10-pack at £1.40 per tray is more competitive.
Coselena is a small business brand on Amazon, which matters to buyers who prefer to support independent sellers over larger commercial operations. The product has 327 reviews at 4.6 stars — solid, though significantly fewer than the ebake (4,687) and Zumart (1,432) in this category.
The Textured Base
The textured underside of the tray is the most distinctive physical feature. On a smooth table, buffet surface, or serving trolley, a flat-based tray can shift when guests reach in to take food. The textured surface creates friction against smooth tabletops and is described in the listing as providing enhanced stability and preventing slipping. This is a practical catering consideration rather than a cosmetic one, and no other tray reviewed in this category includes it. For outdoor events on uneven surfaces, serving trolleys in care or hospitality settings, or any situation where tray movement is a concern, this feature has genuine value.
Dimensions and Height
External dimensions are 33.5 x 24 x 7cm — the same footprint as the Zumart (33.5 x 24cm) but 1cm taller overall. This additional centimetre of combined height over the Zumart makes it comparable to the ebake’s internal height. Despite this, UK reviewer Elizabeth Holland (15-pack buyer) specifically notes that the lids could be a little taller and that triangular sandwich points get squished. The triangular sandwich clearance issue that appears in the Zumart review is not fully resolved by the Coselena’s extra centimetre. If triangular sandwiches are central to your format, measure your prepared sandwiches against the available height before ordering any tray in this category. Rectangular-cut sandwiches, wraps, and finger strips present no issue across all three brands.
Labels Included
Sticker labels are included — described in the listing as clear-top cover for labelling. This is useful for events where multiple trays hold different fillings or dietary categories, and it matches the ebake, which includes allergy stickers. The Zumart does not include labels. For catering settings where dietary labelling is expected, this inclusion adds practical value.
Lids
The AI-generated review summary flags mixed feedback on lid accessibility — customers find them hard to take off. UK reviewer GT (4 stars) describes the lids as fiddly to secure. UK reviewer Elizabeth Holland confirms the lids fit snugly, keeping sandwiches and variety of foods fresh. This appears to be the same pattern seen with other catering tray lids in this category: a tight seal requires deliberate engagement, and the same firmness that keeps food fresh makes removal slightly awkward. Once the technique is familiar, reviewers report no ongoing problem — GT’s 4-star review confirms easy cleaning and reusability despite the initial lid note.
Freshness Performance
Amazon Customer (60th birthday party, 5-pack) confirms the trays kept sandwiches fresh and were small enough to fit in the fridge for prep-ahead storage. Elizabeth Holland confirms the lids fit snugly. UK reviewer Tinileak used the trays for storing many sandwiches fresh for serving. The freshness performance is consistent with the wider category — the lid seal works effectively once engaged properly.
Cost Comparison
At 5-pack entry pricing, the Coselena (£1.88 per tray) is the most expensive option in this category per tray at the smallest pack size. The ebake 6-pack (£1.50) and Zumart 6-pack (£1.33) both offer a lower per-tray entry price. However, the Coselena 10-pack at £1.40 per tray is competitive against the ebake 6-pack — and the Coselena 10-pack adds the textured base and sticker labels. If you are planning to buy 10 or more trays, Coselena pricing is not a meaningful disadvantage. If 5 trays is all you need, the Zumart 6-pack or ebake 6-pack offer better per-unit value.
Verdict
The Coselena is a well-made catering tray with two practical additions over the Zumart: a textured anti-slip base and sticker labels. It shares the same dimensions, freshness performance, and hand-wash-only care as the Zumart, with a slightly taller profile that does not fully resolve the triangular sandwich clearance issue. The 5-pack at £1.88 per tray is priced above the Zumart and ebake entry packs. For buyers who need 10 or more trays and want the textured base, Coselena is a reasonable choice alongside the ebake 6-pack (more reviews, taller internal height) and Zumart 10-pack (more proven, lower per-tray price). The textured base is the standout feature; whether it is worth the premium depends on your serving context.
